In 1842 newly baptized member, Martha Brotherton, claimed that Brigham Young and Joseph Smith pressured her into a quick polygamist marriage. She recorded the event the next day. When it was published, her own sister called her a “liar”. Brigham called her story a “falsehood”. Parley P. Pratt wrote a scathing article to attack Martha. The fascinating story goes beyond a simple case of he said/she said.